12 Movies That Shockingly Beat Better Films For Awards 12 Movies That Shockingly Beat Better Films For Awards

The world of film awards is often filled with surprises, but sometimes, the results can feel downright baffling. In the heat of competition, some films manage to snatch up prestigious awards despite being overshadowed by others in terms of storytelling, direction or acting. Whether due to politics, industry bias or pure surprise moments, these 12 movies shocked audiences by beating out superior films in major award categories.

Shakespeare in Love, 1998 – Saving Private Ryan, 1998

The 1999 Academy Awards saw Shakespeare in Love surprisingly win Best Picture over Saving Private Ryan, widely regarded as one of the greatest war films of all time. While Shakespeare in Love charmed critics with its romantic, witty take on historical fiction, it is hard to deny that Steven Spielberg’s powerful depiction of D-Day and the emotional depth of Saving Private Ryan deserved the honor.

Crash, 2005 – Brokeback Mountain, 2005

At the 2006 Academy Awards, Crash took home the Best Picture statue over Brokeback Mountain, a film that was considered the frontrunner for its raw portrayal of love and sexuality. Crash may have tackled important social issues, but many critics felt its storytelling was less refined and the win was seen as a major upset in what could have been a groundbreaking moment for LGBTQ representation in film.

The English Patient, 1996 – Fargo, 1996

At the 1997 Oscars, The English Patient won Best Picture, despite being considered a slower, more traditional period drama compared to the sharp and darkly comedic Fargo. While both films were well received, the Coen Brothers’ Fargo earned greater acclaim for its originality, performances and its blend of thriller and humor, making the victory of The English Patient a bit of a head scratcher.

Green Book, 2018 – Roma, 2018

In one of the more recent controversial Oscar wins, Green Book took home the Best Picture trophy in 2019, despite Roma being the favorite for its powerful portrayal of a domestic worker in Mexico City. Many critics felt that Roma’s unique, personal storytelling and innovative cinematography should have earned it the top prize, leading to disappointment when Green Book, a film many felt lacked the same level of artistry, triumphed.

A Beautiful Mind, 2001 – The Fellowship of the Ring, 2001

At the 2002 Academy Awards, A Beautiful Mind claimed Best Picture over The Fellowship of the Ring, the first installment of Peter Jackson’s groundbreaking Lord of the Rings trilogy. While A Beautiful Mind was a heartfelt portrayal of mental illness, many felt The Fellowship of the Ring deserved the win for its groundbreaking visual effects, epic scale and cultural impact, which would go on to define modern fantasy cinema.

The Artist, 2011 – Hugo, 2011

In 2012, The Artist, a silent film in black and white, won Best Picture at the Academy Awards, despite Hugo being widely considered a more refined and technically accomplished film. Directed by Martin Scorsese, Hugo blended state of the art technology with a heartfelt tribute to early cinema, while The Artist, though charming, did not quite match up in terms of the depth or innovation seen in Hugo.

The King’s Speech, 2010 – The Social Network, 2010

In one of the most talked about Oscar upsets, The King’s Speech won Best Picture at the 2011 Academy Awards, beating The Social Network, which had received critical acclaim for its sharp writing and exploration of modern day ambition. While The King’s Speech offered a moving story of a monarch overcoming his speech impediment, many felt The Social Network was more relevant and culturally significant, capturing the rise of Facebook and the digital age.

La La Land, 2016 – Moonlight, 2016

In one of the most infamous Oscar blunders, La La Land was initially announced as the winner of Best Picture, only for the award to be corrected moments later to Moonlight. While La La Land was a visually stunning and enjoyable homage to classic Hollywood musicals, Moonlight told a groundbreaking, deeply emotional story about identity, love and race, making it a more deserving winner.

Gladiator, 2000 – Traffic, 2000

At the 2001 Academy Awards, Gladiator took home Best Picture, though many believed Steven Soderbergh’s Traffic was the more deserving film. Traffic was an intense, multifaceted look at the drug trade, while Gladiator’s epic action was praised but arguably lacked the same level of thematic depth and social commentary, making the win for Gladiator somewhat surprising.

The Greatest Showman, 2017 – Lady Bird, 2017

Though Lady Bird was universally loved by critics, The Greatest Showman gained a surprising amount of commercial success, including recognition at the Golden Globes. Many felt that Lady Bird, with its raw, honest exploration of adolescence and mother daughter relationships, was a far more deserving film, particularly in comparison to The Greatest Showman, which was criticized for its somewhat superficial portrayal of showbiz life.

Birdman, 2014 – Boyhood, 2014

In 2015, Birdman took home the Academy Award for Best Picture, beating Richard Linklater’s Boyhood. While Birdman was an inventive film with outstanding performances, many critics argued that Boyhood, filmed over 12 years and capturing the essence of growing up in an unparalleled way, should have been awarded for its ambitious and unique approach to storytelling.

Chicago, 2002 – The Pianist, 2002

While Chicago won Best Picture at the 2003 Academy Awards, many felt Roman Polanski’s The Pianist was the more deserving winner. Chicago was a flashy, high energy musical, but The Pianist offered a haunting, realistic portrayal of survival during World War II, which many thought should have garnered more recognition for its emotional depth and artistic integrity.

While the Academy and other awards bodies are often lauded for their ability to recognize exceptional talent, these surprises show that the path to recognition is not always as straightforward as it seems. Whether due to timing, campaigning or sheer surprise, these films managed to defeat others that many considered more deserving of their prestigious awards. These upsets prove that in the world of film, the race for recognition is unpredictable and sometimes the results are just as memorable as the films themselves.

Disclaimer: This list is solely the author’s opinion based on research and publicly available information.

15 Over The Top Drama Movies That Are Unintentionally Hysterical

Some drama movies aim for deep emotional impact, powerful performances and intense storytelling but sometimes, they miss the mark so spectacularly that they end up being downright hilarious. Whether it’s because of over the top acting, absurd dialogue or bizarre plot twists. These films have gained cult followings for all the wrong reasons. If you love unintentional comedy, these 15 movies deliver drama so exaggerated, they will have you laughing instead of crying.

Read it here:15 Over The Top Drama Movies That Are Unintentionally Hysterical

12 Jaw Dropping Movie Endings That Flipped The Script

Sometimes, even the most talented actors take roles for reasons beyond artistic passion, like a massive paycheck. Whether it is a quick cameo, a half hearted performance or a role that clearly did not suit them, these A-list stars were in it for the money and it showed. Here are 12 movies where big name actors cashed in but left audiences wondering why they even bothered.

Read it here:12 Jaw Dropping Movie Endings That Flipped The Script

12 Jaw Dropping Movie Plot Twists That Were Created Thanks To Test Audiences

Some of the most mind blowing plot twists in movie history did not come from the original script but were actually added after test audiences weighed in. Studios and filmmakers often rely on these screenings to gauge audience reactions and sometimes, their feedback leads to game changing rewrites. Here are 12 jaw dropping movie plot twists that would not exist without test audiences.

Read it here:12 Jaw Dropping Movie Plot Twists That Were Created Thanks To Test Audiences

You’ll love these related posts: